The Economic Consequences of Quebec Sovereignty

Grady, Patrick (1991): The Economic Consequences of Quebec Sovereignty. Published in: Economic Consequences of Quebec Sovereignty (24 September 1991): pp. 143-162.

Abstract

This paper reviews the issues that would arise if Quebec were to separate from Canada. It also presents quantitative estimates of the likely orders of magnitude of their economic impact both on Quebec and the Rest of Canada.

Its overall conclusion is that Quebec would be much harder hit than the rest of Canada if Quebec separates. Real output in Quebec could easily be depressed in the short run by as much as 10 percent and in the long run by 5 percent. In the short run, the output loss would be triggered by a crisis of confidence resulting from separation. In the long run, output loss would be caused by the required transfer of resources to the foreign sector (necessitated by the elimination of the existing fiscal gain in transactions with the federal government), by the emigration of anglophones, and by higher public debt charges resulting from the increased debt burden. The transfer would be made more difficult by the need to ad just in the soft and dairy sectors and by the probable loss of Churchill Falls's power, but it could be facilitated by increased taxes.

For the rest of Canada, the economic costs, which can be quantified, would be substantially lower than for Quebec. And for Canada there also would be some offsetting economic gains. The net short-run costs would only be about one to two percent of GDP and would result mainly from the short-run loss of confidence caused by the separation of Quebec. The long-run quantifiable costs would be small – probably less than the quantifiable benefits.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: economic impact, Quebec separation, break-up of Canada, Sovereignty-Association
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F14 - Empirical Studies of Trade; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E50 - General

References

Commission on the Political and. Constitutional Future of Quebec (1991a) Report.

Commission sur I'avenir politique et constitutionnel du Québec (1991b) Éléments d'analyse économique pertinents a la révision du statut politique et constitutionnel du Québec, Document de travail, numéro 1.

Courchene, Thomas J. (1986) "Market Nationalism," Policy Options, October, pp.7-12.

Courchene, Thomas J. (1991) "Canada 1992: Political Denouement or Economic Renaissance," A Paper Presented at the John Deutsch Conference on Economic Dimensions of Constitutional Change, Queen' University, Kingston, June 4-6.

Fontaine, Mario (1991) "L'indépendance ferait fuir 1 anglophone sur 2," La Presse, April 27, 1991, pp.Al-2.

Gibbon, Ann (1991) "Workers vow not to strike," Globe and Mail, July 5, 1991.

Globe and Mail (1991) "Hydro's controversial and costly policy," Globe and Mail, April 13, 1991.

Gorham, Beth (1991) "Power Play: Bitter memories of a bad deal may poison the future of hydro in Labrador," The Ottawa Citizen, June23, 1991, p.E6.

Grady, Patrick (1991) The Economic Consequences of Quebec Sovereignty (Vancouver: The Fraser Institute). http://global-economics.ca/ec_conseq.htm.

Helliwell, John and Chung, Alan (1991) "Are Bigger Countries Better Off?" A Paper Presented at the John Deutsch Conference on Economic Dimensions of Constitutional Change, Queen’s University, Kingston, June 4-6.

Howitt, Peter (1991) "Constitutional Reform and the Bank of Canada," A Paper Presented at the John Deutsch Conference on Economic Dimensions of Constitutional Change, Queen's University, Kingston, June 4-6.

Macdonald, Don (1991) "Sovereignty will not end monetary ties, Parizeau vows," The Ottawa Citizen, May 28,1991.

Parent, Rollande (1991) "Réconciliation a la grève contre un investissement de 400 a Tracy," Le Devoir, 9 avril 1991, p.A1-4.

Robertson, Gordon (1991) "After 124 Years Canada is too Great a Country to Fail," The Ottawa Citizen, June 9, p.B3).

Varty, David L. (1991) Who Gets Ungava? (Vancouver: Varty & Company Printers).