Returns to Foreign Language Skills in a Developing Country: The Case of Turkey

Di Paolo, Antonio and Tansel, Aysit (2013): Returns to Foreign Language Skills in a Developing Country: The Case of Turkey.

Abstract

Foreign language skills represent a form of human capital that can be rewarded in the labor market. Drawing on data from the Adult Education Survey of 2007, this is the first study estimating returns to foreign language skills in Turkey. We contribute to the literature on the economic value of language knowledge, with a special focus on a country characterized by fast economic and social development. Although English is the most widely spoken foreign language in Turkey, we initially consider the economic value of different foreign languages among the employed males aged 25 to 65. We find positive and significant returns to proficiency in English and Russian, which increase with the level of competence. Knowledge of French and German also appears to be positively rewarded in the Turkish labor market, although their economic value seems mostly linked to an increased likelihood to hold specific occupations rather than increased earnings within occupations. Focusing on English, we also explore the heterogeneity in returns to different levels of proficiency by frequency of English use at work, birth-cohort, education, occupation and rural/urban location. The results are also robust to the endogenous specification of English language skills.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: : Foreign Languages, Returns to Skills, Heterogeneity, Turkey
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I21 - Analysis of Education; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J31 - Wage Level and Structure ; Wage Differentials

References

Adak, M., 2010. Foreign trade and economic growth: The case of Turkey. Middle Eastern Finance and Economics. 8, 137-145.

Adesope, O. O., Lavin, T., Thompson, T., Ungerleider, C., 2010. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the cognitive correlates of bilingualism. Review of Educational Research. 80(2), 207-245.

Adsera, A. and Pytlikova, M., 2012. The role of language in shaping international migration. Institute for the Study of labor Working Paper Series No: 6333, Bonn.

Albouy, D., 2008. The wage gap between Francophones and Anglophones: A Canadian perspective, 1970–2000. Canadian Journal of Economics / Revue Canadienne d’Economique, 41(4), 1211-1238.

Aldashev, A., Gernandt, J., Thomsen, S. L., 2009. Language usage, participation, employment and earnings: Evidence for foreigners in West Germany with multiple sources of selection. Labour Economics. 16, 330-341.

Angrist, J. D., Chin, A., Godoy, R., 2008. Is Spanish-only schooling responsible for the Puerto Rican language gap? Journal of Development Economics. 85(1-2), 105-128.

Angrist, J. D., Lavy, V., 1997. The effect of a change in language of instruction on the returns to schooling in Morocco. Journal of Labor Economics. 15(1), S48-76.

Angrist, J. D., Pischke, J. S., 2008. Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist’s Companion, Princeton University Press, New Jersey.

Arslanturk, Y., Balcilar, M., Ozdemir, Z. A., 2011. Time-varying linkages between tourism receipts and economic growth in a small open economy. Economic Modelling, 28(1-2), 664-671.

Aydın, Y., 2012. Emigration of highly qualified Turks: A critical review of the societal discourses and social scientific research, in: Paçacı-Elitok, S., Straubhaar, T. (Eds), Turkey, Migration and the EU: Potentials, Challenges and Opportunities, Edition HWWI, Institute of International Economics (HWWI), 5(5), Hamburg.

Azam, M., Chin, A., Prakash, N., 2013. The returns to english-language skills in India. Economic Development and Cultural Change. 61(2), 335-367.

Benito, G. R., Gripsrud, G., 1992. The expansion of foreign direct investments: Discrete rational location choices or a cultural learning process? Journal of International Business Studies. 23(3), 461-476.

Berman, E., Lang, K., Siniver, E., 2003. Language skill complementarity: Returns to immigrant language acquisition. Labour Economics. 10(3), 265-90.

Bettin, G., Lucchetti, R., 2012. Interval regression models with endogenous explanatory variables. Empirical Economics. 43(2), 475-49.

Bialystok, E., 1999. Cognitive complexity and attention control in bilingual mind. Child Development. 70(3), 636-644.

Black, D. A., Berger, M. C., Scott, F. A., 2000. Bounding parameter estimates with non-classical measurement error. Journal of the American Statistical Association. 95(451), 739-748.

Bleakley, H., Chin, A., 2004. Language skills and earnings: Evidence from childhood immigrants. The Review of Economics and Statistics. 86(2), 481-96.

Bleakley, H., Chin, A., 2010. Age at arrival, English proficiency, and social assimilation among US immigrants. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics. 2(1), 165-92.

Casale, D., Posel, D., 2011. English language proficiency and earnings in a developing country: The case of South Africa. The Journal of Socio-Economics. 40(4), 385-393.

Cattaneo, A., Winkelmann, R., 2005. Earning differentials between German and French speakers in Switzerland. Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics. 141(2), 191-212.

Cebeci, T., Fernandes, A. M., 2013. Micro dynamics of Turkey’s export boom in the 2000s. The World Bank. Policy Research Working Paper No: 6452, Washington, DC.

Chiswick, B. R., 2008. The economics of language: An introduction and overview. Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) Discussion Paper No: 3568, Bonn.

Chiswick, B. R. Miller, P. W., 1995. The endogeneity between language and earnings: International analyses. Journal of Labor Economics. 13(2), 246-88.

Chiswick, B. R. Miller, P. W., 2007. The Economics of the Language: International Analyses, Routledge, New York.

Chiswick, B. R., Miller, P. W., 2009. Earnings and occupational attainment among immigrants. Industrial Relations. 48(3), 454-465.

Chiswick, B. R., Miller, P. W., 2010. Occupational language requirements and the value of English in the US labor market. Journal of Population Economics. 23, 353-372.

Chiswick, B. R., Miller, P. W., 2013. The impact of surplus skills on earnings: Extending the over-education model to language proficiency. Economics of Education Review. 36, 263-275.

Church, J., King, I., 1993. Bilingualism and network externalities. Canadian Journal of Economics. 26, 337-245.

Cooper, T. C., 1987. Foreign language study and SAT-Verbal Scores, The Modern Language Journal. 71(4), 381-387.

Crystal, D., 2008. Two thousand million? English Today. 24(1), 3-6.

Çetinkaya, M., Erdoğan, S., 2010. VAR analysis of the relation between GDP, import, and export: Turkey case. International Research Journal of Finance and Economics. 55, 135-145.

Di Paolo, A., 2011. Knowledge of Catalan, public/private sector choice and earnings: Evidence from a double sample selection model. Hacienda Pública Española/Review of Public Economics. 197(2), 9-35.

Di Paolo, A., Raymond, J. L., 2012. Language knowledge and earnings in Catalonia. Journal of Applied Economics. 15(1), 89-118.

Dustmann, C., 1994. Speaking fluency, writing fluency and earnings of migrants. Journal of Population Economics. 7(1), 133-56.

Dustmann, C. Fabbri, F., 2003. Language proficiency and labour market performance of immigrants in the UK. Economic Journal. 113(489), 695-717.

Dustmann, C., van Soest, A., 2001. Language fluency and earnings: Estimation with misclassified language indicators. The Review of Economics and Statistics. 83(4), 663-674.

Dustmann, C., van Soest, A., 2002. Language and the earnings of immigrants. Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 55(3), 473-92.

Dustmann, C., van Soest, A., 2004. An analysis of speaking fluency of immigrants using ordered response models with classification errors. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics. 22, 312-321.

Education First, (2011 and 2012) Education First English Proficiency Index. (Available at www.ef.com/epi).

European Union, 2006. Europeans and their languages. Special Euro-Barometer 386/Wave EB77.1 (available at http://ec.europa.eu/languages/documents/2006-special-eurobarometer-survey-64.3europeans-and-languages-report_en.pdf).

European Union, 2012. Europeans and their languages, Special Euro-Barometer 243/Wave 64.3 (available at http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/archives/ebs/ebs_386_en.pdf).

Eurostat, 2012. Gross Domestic Expenditure on R&D as Percent Share of GDP (available at http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/statistics_explained/index.php/R_%26_D_expenditure).

Federal Statistical Office of Germany (2013) Accessed on October 9, 2013: (available at https://www.destatis.de).

Fidrmuc, J., 2011. The economics of multilingualism in the EU, in: Eger, T., Schäfer H-B. (Eds.), Research Handbook on the Economics of European Union Law. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp. 331-352.

Fidrmuc, J., Fidrmuc, J., 2009. Foreign languages and trade. Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR) Discussion Paper No:7228, London.

Gabszewicz, J., Ginsburgh, V., Laussel, D., Weber, S., 2011a. Foreign languages acquisition: Self-Learning and language schools.

Gabszewicz, J., Ginsburgh, V., Laussel, D., Weber, S., 2011b. Bilingualism and communicative benefits, annals of economics and statistics. Annales d'Économie et de Statistique. 101/102, 271-286.

Galasi, P., 2003. Estimating wage equations for Hungarian higher education graduates. Budapest Working Papers on the Labour Market.

Ginsburgh, V. A., Laussel, D., Weber, S., 2011. Foreign language acquisition: Self-Learning and language schools. Review of Network Economics. 10(1), 1446-9022, DOI: 10.2202/1446-9022.1185.

Ginsburgh, V. A., Ortuno-Ortin, I., Weber, S., 2007. Learning foreign languages. Theoretical and empirical implications of the Selten and Pool model. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization. 64, 337-347.

Ginsburgh, V. A., Prieto-Rodriguez, J., 2011. Returns to foreign languages of native workers in the EU, Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 64(3), 599-617.

Grin, F., Sfreddo, C., 1998. Language-based earnings differentials on the Swiss labour market: Is Italian a liability? International Journal of Manpower. 19(7), 520-532.

Grin, F., Sfreddo, C. Vaillancourt, F., 2010. The Economics of the Multilingual Workplace. Routledge, New York.

Gunduz, L., Abdulnasser-Hatemi, J., 2005. Is the tourism-led growth hypothesis valid for Turkey? Applied Economics Letters. 12(8), 499-504.

He, D, Li, D. C. S., 2009. Language attitudes and linguistic features in the ‘China English’ debate. World Englishes. 28(1), 70-89.

Henley, A., Jones, R. E., 2005. Earnings and linguistic proficiency in a bilingual economy. The Manchester School. 73(3), 300-320.

Hoon, C. O., Selmier, W. T., Lien, D., 2011. International trade, foreign direct investment, and transaction costs in languages. The Journal of Socio-Economics. 40(6), 732-735.

Howitt, P., 1999. Steady endogenous growth with population and R&D inputs growing. Journal of Political Economy. 107, 715-730.

Hutchinson, William K. 2005. Linguistic Distance" as a Determinant of Bilateral Trade. Southern Economic Journal. 72(1), 1–15.

Isphording, I., Otten, S., 2013. The costs of Babylon – Linguistic distance in applied economics. Review of International Economics. 21(2), 354-369.

Kane, T. J., Rouse, C. E., Staiger, D., 1999. Estimating returns to schooling when schooling is misreported. National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) Working Paper No: 7235, Cambridge, MA.

Karabag, S. F., Tuncay-Celikel, A., Berggren, C., 2011. The limits of R&D internationalization and the importance of local initiatives: Turkey as a critical case. World Development. 39(8), 1347-1357.

Klein, C., 2003. La valorisation des compétences linguistiques sur le marché du travail luxembourgeois. CEPS/INSTEAD Working Paper No: 139, Luxemburg.

Kogut, B., Harbir, S., 1988. The effect of national culture on the choice of entry mode. Journal of International Business Studies. 19(3), 411-432.

Koru, S., Akesson, J., 2011. Türkiye’de ingilizce açığı, (English language deficiency in Turkey): Türkiye Ekonomi Politikalari Araştırma Vakfı Politika Notu No: N201157, Ankara.

Kotil, E., Konur, F., 2010. The relationship between growth and foreign trade in Turkey: A granger causality approach (1989-2007). Middle Eastern Finance and Economics. 1(6), 32-40.

Ku, H., Zussmann, A., 2010. Lingua Franca: The role of English in international trade. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization. 75, 250-260.

Lang, K., Siniver, E., 2009. The return to English in a non-English speaking country: Russian immigrants and native Israelis in Israel. The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy. 9(1), 1-30.

Leikin, M., 2012. The effect of bilingualism on creativity: Developmental and educational perspectives. International Journal of Bilingualism. 10(10), 1-17.

Leslie, D., Lindley, J., 2001. The impact of language ability on employment and earnings of Britain’s ethnic communities. Economica. 68(272), 587-606.

Leslie, D., Russell, H., Forbes, A., 2002. Foreign language skills and tourism management courses in the UK. Industry and Higher Education. 16(6), 403-414.

Levinsohn, J., 2007. Globalization and the returns to speaking English in South Africa, in: Harrison, A. E., (Ed.), Globalization and Poverty. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 629-646.

Melitz, J., 2008. Language and foreign trade. European Economic Review. 52, 667-699.

Olsen, S., Brown, L. K., 1992. The relation between high school study of foreign language and ACT English and Mathematics performance. Association of Departments of Foreign Languages (ADFL) Bulletin. 23(3), 47-50.

Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD) (2012) OECD Economic Surveys: Turkey. OECD Publications. Paris (DOI: 10.1787/eco_surveys-tur-2012-en).

Özçelik, E., Taymaz, E., 2008. R&D support programs in developing countries ― the Turkish case. Research Policy. 37(2), 258.275.

Öztürk, İ., Acaravcı, A., 2010. Testing the export-led growth hypothesis: Empirical evidence from Turkey. The Journal of Developing Areas. 44(1), 245-254.

Quella, N., Rendon, S., 2012. Occupational selection in multilingual labor markets: The case of Catalonia. International Journal of Manpower. 33(8), 918-937.

Rendon, S., 2007. The Catalan premium: Language and employment in Catalonia. Journal of Population Economics. 20(3), 669-686.

Roodman, D., 2011. Fitting fully observed recursive mixed-process models with cmp, The Stata Journal. 11(2), 159-206.

Rupérez-Micola, A., Bris, A., Banal-Estañol, A., 2012. TV or not TV? Subtitling and English skills. Department of Economics and Business, Working Paper No:1156, Universitat Pompeu Fabra (available at http://albertbanalestanol.com/wp-content/uploads/TV-or-not-TV-Subtitling-and-English-Skills.pdf).

Saiz, A., Zoido, E., 2005. Listening to what the world Says: Bilingualism and earnings in the United States. The Review of Economics and Statistics. 87(3), 523-538.

Seargeant, P., Erling, E., 2011. The discourse of English as a language for international development: Policy assumptions and practical challenges, in Coleman, H. (Ed.), Dreams and Realities: Developing Countries and the English Language. British Council, London, pp. 255-274.

Segerstrom, P., 2000. The long-run growth effects of R&D subsidies. Journal of Economic Growth. 5, 277-305.

Selten, R., Pool, J., 1991. The distribution of foreign language skills as a game equilibrium, in: Reinhard S. (Ed.), Game Equilibrium Models. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 64-84.

Shapiro, D., Stelcner, M., 1997. Language earnings in Quebec: Trends Over Twenty Years,1970–1990. Canadian Public Policy. 23(2), 115-40.

Shields, M. A., Price, W. S., 2002. The English language fluency and occupational success of ethnic minority immigrant men living in English metropolitan areas. Journal of Population Economics. 15(1), 137-160.

State Planning Organization (SPO) (2006) Ninth Five-Year Development Plan 2007-2013. SPO Publications. Ankara.

Stewart, M., 1983. On least squares estimation when the dependent variable is grouped. Review of Economic Studies. 50(4), 737-5.

Tansel, A., 1994. Wage employment, earnings and returns to schooling for men and women in Turkey. Economics of Education Review. 13(4), 305-320.

Tansel, A., 1996. Self-employment, wage employment and returns to education for urban men and women in Turkey in education and the labor market in Turkey. in: Bulutay, T. State Institute of Statistics (SIS) Publication. Ankara, pp.175-208.

Tansel, A., 2010. Changing returns to education for men and women in a developing country: Turkey, 1994-2005, paper presented at the European Society for Population Economics (ESPE) Conference, London, UK and at the Middle East Economic Association (MEEA) Conference, March 2009 in Nice, France.

Tansel, A., 2012. 2050’ye Doğru nüfus bilim ve yönetim: İşgücü piyasasına bakış, TUSIAD and UNFPA. Publication No: Tüsiad-T/2012-11/536, İstanbul.

Tansel, A., Kan, E. O., 2012. The formal/informal employment earnings gap: evidence from Turkey. Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) Discussion Paper No: 6556, Bonn.

Tansel, A. Ya şar, P. 2010. Macroeconomic impact of remittances on output growth: Evidence from Turkey. Migration Letters. 7(2), 132-143.

Toomet, O., 2011. Learn English, Not the local language! Ethnic Russians in the Baltic States. American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings. 101(3), 526-531.

Tucci, I., Wagner, G. G., 2004. Foreign language skills- an important additional qualification in the services sector, Economic Bulletin. 41, 43-46.

Turkish Demographic Health Survey (TDHS), 2008. Turkish Demographic Health Survey, 2008. Hacettepe University Institute of Population Studies. Ankara.

Turkish Statistical Institute (TURKSTAT), (2012) Informal Education in Turkey, Turkish Statistical Institute Publication. Ankara.

Turkish Statistical Institute (TURKSTAT) (2010), Adult Education Survey, 2007. Turkish Statistical Institute Publication.No:3433. Ankara (available at http://www.tuik.gov.tr/Kitap.do?metod=KitapDetay&KT_ID=5&KITAP_ID=218).

Turkish Statistical Institute (TURKSTAT) 2013 (available at www.tuik.gov.tr).

United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) 2013. World Investment Report. United Nations Publications. Geneva (available at http://unctad.org/en/PublicationsLibrary/wir2013_en.pdf).

Williams, D., 2011. The economic returns to multiple language usage in Western Europe. International Journal of Manpower. 32(4), 372-393.

World Bank, 2011. Improving the quality and equity of basic education in Turkey: Challenges and options. Human Development Department, Europe and Central Asia Region Report No: 54131, Washington DC.

World Bank, 2013. Promoting excellence in Turkey’s schools. Human Development Sector Unit Europe and Central Asia Region Report No: 77722, Washington DC.

Yağmur, K., 2001. Languages in Turkey. in: Extra, G. and Gorter, D. (Eds.), The Other Languages of Europe. European Cultural Foundation, Clevedon, UK.