Uncertainty, Learning, and Local Opposition to Hydraulic Fracturing

Hess, Joshua and Manning, Dale and Iverson, Terry and Cutler, Harvey (2016): Uncertainty, Learning, and Local Opposition to Hydraulic Fracturing.

Abstract

The development of oil and gas extraction technologies, including hydraulic fracturing (fracking), has increased fossil fuel reserves in the US. Despite benefits, uncertainty over environmental damages has led to fracking bans, both permanent and temporary, in many jurisdictions. We develop a stochastic dynamic learning model parameterized with a computable general equilibrium model to explore if uncertainty about damages, combined with the ability to learn about risks, can explain fracking bans in practice. Applying the model to a representative Colorado municipality, we quantify the quasi-option value (QOV), which creates an additional incentive to ban fracking temporarily in order to learn, though it only influences policy in a narrow range of oil and gas prices. To our knowledge, this is the first attempt to quantify an economy-wide QOV associated with a local environmental policy decision.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: hydraulic fracturing; quasi-option value; stochastic dynamic program; computable general equilibrium model
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling > C61 - Optimization Techniques ; Programming Models ; Dynamic Analysis; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling > C68 - Computable General Equilibrium Models; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q3 - Nonrenewable Resources and Conservation > Q34 - Natural Resources and Domestic and International Conflicts; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q3 - Nonrenewable Resources and Conservation > Q38 - Government Policy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy

References

Aguilera, Inmaculada, Guxens, M., Garcia-Esteban, R., Corbella, T., Nieuwenhuijsen, M. J., Foradada, C. M., & Sunyer, J. "Association between GIS-based exposure to urban air pollution during pregnancy and birth weight in the INMA Sabadell Cohort." Environmental health perspectives 117.8 (2009): 1322.

Allcott, Hunt, and Daniel Keniston. Dutch disease or agglomeration? The local economic effects of natural resource booms in modern America. No. w20508. National Bureau of Economic Research (2014).

Arrow, Kenneth J., and Anthony C. Fisher. "Environmental preservation, uncertainty, and irreversibility." The Quarterly Journal of Economics (1974): 312-319.

Bennett, Ashley, and John Loomis. "Are Housing Prices Pulled Down or Pushed Up by Fracked Oil and Gas Wells? A Hedonic Price Analysis of Housing Values in Weld County, Colorado." Society & Natural Resources (2015): 1-19.

Bond, Craig A., and John B. Loomis. "Using numerical dynamic programming to compare passive and active learning in the adaptive management of nutrients in shallow lakes." Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie 57.4 (2009): 555-573.

Boxall, Peter C., Wing H. Chan, and Melville L. McMillan. "The impact of oil and natural gas facilities on rural residential property values: a spatial hedonic analysis." Resource and energy economics 27.3 (2005): 248-269.

Brown, Jason P., Timothy Ryan Fitzgerald, and Jeremy Glenn Weber. "Capturing rents from natural resource abundance: Private royalties from us onshore oil & gas production." Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Working Paper 15-04 (2015).

Center for Business and Economic Research (CBER). Projecting the Economic Impact of the Fayetteville Shale Play for 2008-2012 (2008). University of Arkansas College of Business.

Chen, Dafang, Sung-Il Cho, Changzhong Chen, Xiaobin Wang, Andrew I. Damokosh, Louise Ryan, Thomas J. Smith, David C. Christiani, and Xiping Xu "Exposure to benzene, occupational stress, and reduced birth weight." Occupational and environmental medicine 57.10 (2000): 661-667.

Chichilnisky, Graciela, and Geoffrey Heal. "Global Environmental Risks." The Journal of Economic Perspectives (1993): 65-86.

City of Fort Collins. Fort Collins Utilities. 2015 Water Efficiency Program. Feb. 2016. Web. 12 Aug. 2016. <http://www.fcgov.com/utilities/img/site_specific/uploads/WEP_2015-17_FullDraft_NoWaterMark_v9.pdf >.

Considine, Timothy J., Robert Watson, and Seth Blumsack. "The economic impacts of the Pennsylvania Marcellus shale natural gas play: an update." The Pennsylvania State University, Department of Energy and Mineral Engineering (2010).

Cutler, Harvey, and Stephen Davies. "The Impact Of Specific‐Sector Changes In Employment On Economic Growth, Labor Market Performance And Migration." Journal of Regional Science 47.5 (2007): 935-963.

Dixit, Avinash K., and Robert S. Pindyck. "Investment under uncertainty." Princeton UP, Princeton (1994).

Energy Commerce Committee, U. H. o. R. (2011). Chemicals used in hydraulic fracturing.

Epstein, Larry G. "Decision making and the temporal resolution of uncertainty." International economic review (1980): 269-283.

Fisher, Anthony C., and Urvashi Narain. "Global warming, endogenous risk, and irreversibility." Environmental and Resource Economics 25.4 (2003): 395-416.

Fitzgerald, Timothy, and Randal R. Rucker. "US private oil and natural gas royalties: estimates and policy relevance." OPEC Energy Review 40.1 (2016): 3-25. Fitzgerald, Timothy, “Regional Windfalls or Beverly Hillbillies? Local and Absentee Ownership of Oil and Gas Royalties.” Association of Environmental and Resource Econonmists 5th Annual Summer Conference. June 9-11.

Graham, John D., John Rupp, and Olga Schenk. "Unconventional Gas Development in the USA: Exploring the Risk Perception Issues." Conference Paper, Harvard School of Public Health, Harvard Center for Risk Analysis. 2014.

Gopalakrishnan, Sathya, and H. Allen Klaiber. "Is the shale energy boom a bust for nearby residents? evidence from housing values in pennsylvania." American Journal of Agricultural Economics 96.1 (2014): 43-66.

Hanemann, W. Michael. "Information and the concept of option value." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 16.1 (1989): 23-37.

Hausman, Catherine, and Ryan Kellogg. Welfare and Distributional Implications of Shale Gas. No. w21115. National Bureau of Economic Research, 2015.

Henry, Claude. "Option values in the economics of irreplaceable assets." The Review of Economic Studies (1974): 89-104

Hill, Elaine L. "Shale gas development and infant health: evidence from Pennsylvania." Charles H. Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management, Cornell University, Working Paper. Available at (2013).

Holling, Crawford S., and Gary K. Meffe. "Command and control and the pathology of natural resource management." Conservation biology 10.2 (1996): 328-337.

Jackson, R. B., Vengosh, A., Carey, J. W., Davies, R. J., Darrah, T. H., O’Sullivan, F., and P ́etron, G. (2014). The environmental costs and benefits of fracking. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 39(1):327–362.

Jacobsen, Grant D., and Dominic P. Parker. "The economic aftermath of resource booms: evidence from boomtowns in the American West." The Economic Journal (2014).

Jensen, Svenn, and C. P. Traeger. "Optimally climate sensitive policy under uncertainty and learning." Working Paper. 2013.

Karp, Larry and Zhang, Jiangfeng. (2006). “Regulation with anticipated learning about environmental damages.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 51(3), 259-279.

Kelly, David L., and Charles D. Kolstad. "Bayesian learning, growth, and pollution." Journal of economic dynamics and control 23.4 (1999): 491-518.

Kinnaman, Thomas C. "The economic impact of shale gas extraction: A review of existing studies." Ecological Economics 70.7 (2011): 1243-1249

Kolstad, Charles D. "Fundamental irreversibilities in stock externalities." Journal of Public Economics 60.2 (1996a): 221-233.

Kolstad, Charles D. "Learning and stock effects in environmental regulation: the case of greenhouse gas emissions." Journal of environmental economics and management 31.1 (1996b): 1-18.

Krupnick, Alan J., and Hal G. Gordon. "What Experts Say About the Environmental Risks of Shale Gas Development." Agricultural and Resource Economics Review 44.2 (2015): 106-119.

Krupnick, Alan, Zhongmin Wang, and Yushuang Wang. "Environmental risks of shale gas development in China." Energy Policy 75 (2014): 117-125.

Leach, Andrew J. "The climate change learning curve." Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 31.5 (2007): 1728-1752.

Lemoine, Derek, and Christian Traeger. "Watch your step: Optimal policy in a tipping climate." American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 6.1 (2014): 137-166.

Maniloff, Peter, and Ralph Mastromonaco. The Local Economic Impacts of Fracking. Working Paper, http://pages. uoregon. edu/ralphm/fracking_ may_15. pdf, (2015).

Mensink, Paul, and Till Requate. "The Dixit–Pindyck and the Arrow–Fisher–Hanemann–Henry option values are not equivalent: a note on Fisher (2000)." Resource and Energy Economics 27.1 (2005): 83-88.

Muehlenbachs, Lucija, Elisheba Spiller, and Christopher Timmins. 2015. "The Housing Market Impacts of Shale Gas Development." American Economic Review, 105(12): 3633-59.

Pew Research Center for the People and the Press, 2012. As Gas Prices Pinch, Support for Oil and Gas Production Grows [WWW Document]. Pew Res. Cent. People Press. URL 〈http://www.people-press.org/2012/03/19/as-gas-price s-pinch-support-for-oil-and-gas-production-grows/〉.

Pindyck, Robert S. "Irreversibility, Uncertainty, and Investment." Journal of Economic Literature (1991): 1110-1148.

Prato, Tony. "Bayesian adaptive management of ecosystems." Ecological Modelling 183.2 (2005): 147-156.

Shonkoff, Seth BC, Jake Hays, and Madelon L. Finkel. "Environmental public health dimensions of shale and tight gas development." Environmental Health Perspectives (Online) 122.8 (2014): 787.

Slama, Rémy, et al. "Maternal personal exposure to airborne benzene and intrauterine growth." Environmental health perspectives 117.8 (2009): 1313-21.

Thrower, Alex W., and J. Michael Martinez. "Reconciling anthropocentrism and biocentrism through adaptive management: the case of the waste isolation pilot plant and public risk perception." The Journal of Environment & Development 9.1 (2000): 68-97.

Traeger, Christian P. "Closed-Form Integrated Assessment and Uncertainty." (2015).

Traeger, Christian P. "On option values in environmental and resource economics." Resource and Energy Economics (2014).

Timmins, Christopher, and Ashley Vissing. "Shale Gas Leases: Is bargaining efficient and what are the implications for homeowners if it is not?." (2014).

Ulph, Alistair, and David Ulph. “Global warming, irreversibility and learning.” The Economic Journal 107.442 (1997): 636-650.

Walters, Carl. "Adaptive management of renewable resources." (1986). Weber, Jeremy G. "The effects of a natural gas boom on employment and income in Colorado, Texas, and Wyoming." Energy Economics 34.5 ( 2012): 1580-1588.

Weisbrod, Burton A. "Collective-consumption services of individual-consumption goods." The Quarterly Journal of Economics 78.3 (1964): 471-477.

Wobbekind, Richard, and Brian Lewandowski. "Hydraulic Fracturing Ban: The Economic Impact of a Statewide Fracking Ban in Colorado." The Business Research Division, Leeds School of Business, The University of Colorado Boulder (2014).

Zahran, Sammy, Stephan Weiler, Howard W. Mielke, and Anita Alves Pena. "Maternal benzene exposure and low birth weight risk in the United States: A natural experiment in gasoline reformulation." Environmental research 112 (2012): 139-146.