Improving Underlying Scenarios for Aggregate Forecasts: A Multi-level Combination Approach

Cobb, Marcus P A (2018): Improving Underlying Scenarios for Aggregate Forecasts: A Multi-level Combination Approach.

Abstract

Abstract In some situations forecasts for a number of sub-aggregations are required for analysis in addition to the aggregate itself. In this context, practitioners typically rely on bottom-up methods to produce a set of consistent forecasts in order to avoid conflicting messages. However, using this approach exclusively can mean that forecasting accuracy is negatively affected when compared to using other methods. This paper presents a method for increasing overall accuracy by jointly combining the forecasts for an aggregate, any sub-aggregations, and the components from any number of models and measurement approaches. The framework seeks to benefit from the strengths of each of the forecasting approaches by accounting for their reliability in the combination process and exploiting the constraints that the aggregation structure imposes on the set of forecasts as a whole. The results from the empirical application suggest that the method is successful in allowing the strengths of the better-performing approaches to contribute to increasing the performance of the rest.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Bottom-up forecasting; Forecast combination; Hierarchical forecasting; Reconciling forecasts
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling > C53 - Forecasting and Prediction Methods ; Simulation Methods; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E27 - Forecasting and Simulation: Models and Applications; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E37 - Forecasting and Simulation: Models and Applications

References

Aiolfi, M. and C. A. Favero (2005). Model uncertainty, thick modelling and the predictability of stock returns. Journal of Forecasting 24(4), 233–254.

Alessi, L., E. Ghysels, L. Onorante, R. Peach, and S. Potter (2014). Central bank macroeconomic forecasting during the global financial crisis: the European Central Bank and Federal Reserve Bank of New York experiences. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 32(4), 483–500.

Antipa, P., K. Barhoumi, V. Brunhes-Lesage, and O. Darné (2012). Nowcasting German GDP: A comparison of bridge and factor models. Journal of Policy Modeling 34(6), 864–878.

Aron, J. and J. Muellbauer (2012). Improving forecasting in an emerging economy, south africa: Changing trends, long run restrictions and disaggregation. International Journal of Forecasting 28(2), 456–476.

Aruoba, S. B., F. X. Diebold, J. Nalewaik, F. Schorfheide, and D. Song (2013). Improving US GDP measurement: A forecast combination perspective. In Recent Advances and Future Directions in Causality, Prediction, and Specification Analysis, pp. 1–25. Springer.

Banbura, M., D. Giannone, and L. Reichlin (2010). Large Bayesian vector auto regressions. Journal of Applied Econometrics 25(1), 71–92.

Bates, J. M. and C. W. Granger (1969). The combination of forecasts. Operations Research Quarterly 20, 451–468.

Bell, V., L. W. Co, S. Stone, and G. Wallis (2014). Nowcasting UK GDP growth. Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin 54(1), 58–68.

Benalal, N., J. L. Diaz del Hoyo, B. Landau, M. Roma, and F. Skudelny (2004). To aggregate or not to aggregate? Euro area inflation forecasting. Working Paper 374, European Central Bank.

Burriel, P. (2012). A real-time disaggregated forecasting model for the Euro area GDP. Economic Bulletin, 93–103.

Chauvet, M. and S. Potter (2013). Forecasting output. Handbook of Economic Forecasting 2(Part A), 141–194.

Clark, T. E. (2004). An evaluation of the decline in goods inflation. Economic ReviewFederal Reserve Bank of Kansas City 89(2), 19. 46

Conflitti, C., C. De Mol, and D. Giannone (2015). Optimal combination of survey forecasts. International Journal of Forecasting 31(4), 1096–1103.

Dalgaard, E. and C. Gysting (2004). An algorithm for balancing commodity-flow systems. Economic Systems Research 16(2), 169–190.

Denton, F. T. (1971). Adjustment of monthly or quarterly series to annuals totals: An approach based on quadratic minimization. Journal of the American Statistical Association 66(333), 99–102.

Diebold, F. X. and R. S. Mariano (1995). Comparing predictive accuracy. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 13(3), 253–263.

Drechsel, K. and R. Scheufele (2013). Bottom-up or direct? Forecasting German GDP in a data-rich environment. IWH Discussion Papers 7, Halle Institute for Economic Research.

Eklund, J. and S. Karlsson (2007). Forecast combination and model averaging using predictive measures. Econometric Reviews 26(2-4), 329–363.

Elliott, G. (2017). Forecast combination when outcomes are difficult to predict. Empirical Economics 53(1), 7–20.

Espasa, A. and I. Mayo-Burgos (2013). Forecasting aggregates and disaggregates with common features. International Journal of Forecasting 29(4), 718–732.

Espasa, A. and E. Senra (2017). Twenty-two years of inflation assessment and forecasting experience at the bulletin of eu & us inflation and macroeconomic analysis. Econometrics 5(4), 44.

Espasa, A., E. Senra, and R. Albacete (2002). Forecasting inflation in the European Monetary Union: A disaggregated approach by countries and by sectors. The European Journal of Finance 8(4), 402–421.

Esteves, P. S. (2013). Direct vs bottom–up approach when forecasting GDP: Reconciling literature results with institutional practice. Economic Modelling 33, 416–420.

Forni, M., M. Hallin, M. Lippi, and L. Reichlin (2005). The generalized dynamic factor model. Journal of the American Statistical Association 100(471).

Frale, C., M. Marcellino, G. L. Mazzi, and T. Proietti (2011). EUROMIND: A monthly indicator of the euro area economic conditions. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society) 174(2), 439–470. 47

Giannone, D., M. Lenza, D. Momferatou, and L. Onorante (2014). Short-term inflation projections: A Bayesian vector autoregressive approach. International Journal of Forecasting 30(3), 635–644.

Gomez, V. and A. Maravall (1996). Programs TRAMO and SEATS. Instructions for the User. Working paper, Banco de Espana. 9628, Research Department, Bank of Spain.

Goodhart, C. (2004). Gradualism in the adjustment of official interest rates: Some partial explanations. Financial Markets Group special paper. Technical Report 157, London School of Economics.

Granger, C. W. (1987). Implications of aggregation with common factors. Econometric Theory 3(02), 208–222.

Granger, C. W. and R. Ramanathan (1984). Improved methods of combining forecasts. Journal of Forecasting 3(2), 197–204.

Hahn, E. and F. Skudelny (2008). Early estimates of Euro area real GDP growth: a bottom up approach from the production side. Working Paper Series 0975, European Central Bank.

Hansen, B. E. (2008). Least-squares forecast averaging. Journal of Econometrics 146(2), 342–350.

Hargreaves, D., H. Kite, B. Hodgetts, et al. (2006). Modelling new zealand inflation in a phillips curve. Reserve Bank of New Zealand Bulletin 69(3), 23–37.

Harvey, D., S. Leybourne, and P. Newbold (1997). Testing the equality of prediction mean squared errors. International Journal of forecasting 13(2), 281–291.

Hendry, D. F. and K. Hubrich (2011). Combining disaggregate forecasts or combining disaggregate information to forecast an aggregate. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 29(2).

Higgins, P. C. (2014). GDPNow: A Model for GDP "Nowcasting". FRB Atlanta Working Paper 2014-7, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta.

Hoogerheide, L., R. Kleijn, F. Ravazzolo, H. K. Van Dijk, and M. Verbeek (2010). Forecast accuracy and economic gains from Bayesian model averaging using time-varying weights. Journal of Forecasting 29(1-2), 251–269.

Hsiao, C. and S. K. Wan (2014). Is there an optimal forecast combination? Journal of Econometrics 178, 294–309. 48

Hubrich, K. (2005). Forecasting Euro area inflation: Does aggregating forecasts by HICP component improve forecast accuracy? International Journal of Forecasting 21(1), 119–136.

Hubrich, K. and F. Skudelny (2017). Forecast combination for euro area inflation: a cure in times of crisis? Journal of Forecasting 36(5), 515–540.

Hyndman, R. J., R. A. Ahmed, G. Athanasopoulos, and H. L. Shang (2011). Optimal combination forecasts for hierarchical time series. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis 55(9), 2579–2589.

Jacobs, D. and T. Williams (2014, September). The Determinants of Non-tradables Inflation. RBA Bulletin, 27–38.

Johnson, N. (2017, 05). Tradable and nontradable inflation indexes: Replicating new zealand’s tradable indexes with bls cpi data. 2017.

Kapetanios, G., V. Labhard, and S. Price (2008). Forecasting using Bayesian and information-theoretic model averaging: An application to UK inflation. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 26(1), 33–41.

Lütkepohl, H. (1987). Forecasting aggregated vector ARMA processes, Volume 284. Springer Science & Business Media.

Marcellino, M. (2008). A linear benchmark for forecasting GDP growth and inflation? Journal of Forecasting 27(4), 305–340.

Marcellino, M., J. H. Stock, and M. W. Watson (2003). Macroeconomic forecasting in the Euro area: Country specific versus area-wide information. European Economic Review 47(1), 1–18.

Mogliani, M., O. Darné, and B. Pluyaud (2017). The new MIBA model: Real-time nowcasting of French GDP using the Banque de France’s monthly business survey. Economic Modelling 64(Supplement C), 26 – 39.

Pavia-Miralles, J. (2010). A survey of methods to interpolate, distribute and extrapolate time series. Journal of Service Science and Management 3(4), 449–463.

Peach, R. W., R. W. Rich, and M. H. Linder (2013). The parts are more than the whole: separating goods and services to predict core inflation. Current Issues in Economics and Finance 19(7).

Perevalov, N. and P. Maier (2010). On the advantages of disaggregated data: Insights from forecasting the US economy in a data-rich environment. Working Papers 10-10, Bank of Canada. 49

Ravazzolo, F. and S. P. Vahey (2014). Forecast densities for economic aggregates from disaggregate ensembles. Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics & Econometrics 18(4), 367– 381.

Rodrigues, J. F. (2014). A Bayesian approach to the balancing of statistical economic data. Entropy 16(3), 1243–1271.

Smith, J. and K. F. Wallis (2009). A simple explanation of the forecast combination puzzle. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 71(3), 331–355.

Stock, J. and M. Watson (1999). A comparison of linear and nonlinear univariate models for forecasting macroeconomic time series. in R.F. Engle and H. White, eds., Festschrift in Honour of Clive Granger (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) 1-44.

Stock, J. H. and M. W. Watson (1998). Diffusion indexes. Working Paper 6702, NBER.

Stock, J. H. and M. W. Watson (2015). Core inflation and trend inflation. Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Tallman, E. W. and S. Zaman (2017). Forecasting inflation: Phillips curve effects on services price measures. International Journal of Forecasting 33(2), 442–457.

Timmermann, A. (2006). Forecast combinations. Handbook of economic forecasting 1, 135–196.

Wei, X. and Y. Yang (2012). Robust forecast combinations. Journal of Econometrics 166(2), 224–236.

Zellner, A. and J. Tobias (2000). A note on aggregation, disaggregation and forecasting performance. Journal of Forecasting 19(5), 457–465.