Two Opposing Economic-Literary Critiques of Socialism: George Orwell Versus Eugen Richter and Henry Hazlitt

Makovi, Michael (2015): Two Opposing Economic-Literary Critiques of Socialism: George Orwell Versus Eugen Richter and Henry Hazlitt. Forthcoming in: International Journal of Pluralism and Economics Education No. Forthcoming

Abstract

Orwell's famous fictions, Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four criticized totalitarian forms of socialism from a Public Choice perspective, assuming that socialism would work as an economic system as long as the proper political institutions were in place to curb the potential for the abuse of power. This is contrasted with two novels by others who took the opposite approach: Richter's Pictures of the Socialistic Future and Hazlitt's Time Will Run Back. These two assumed that the political implementation of socialism would be perfect but that socialism would necessarily turn totalitarian because of the problem of economic calculation. These novels assumed away the Public Choice problem of institutions and the abuse of power and focused on the political implications of socialism as a purely economic system. Contrasting these two sets of novels shows how the Austrian and Public Choice schools criticize socialism in two entirely different ways.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Orwell; Richter; Hazlitt; democratic socialism; market socialism; totalitarianism
• Subjects: A - General Economics and Teaching > A1 - General Economics > A12 - Relation of Economics to Other Disciplines; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B24 - Socialist ; Marxist ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B25 - Historical ; Institutional ; Evolutionary ; Austrian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Economic Thought: Individuals > B31 - Individuals; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B51 - Socialist ; Marxian ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B53 - Austrian; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D70 - General; P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P11 - Planning, Coordination, and Reform; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P20 - General; P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P30 - General; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology > Z11 - Economics of the Arts and Literature

References

Bloom, Harold. (ed.) (1987a). George Orwell (Modern Critical Views). New York / New Haven / Philadelphia: Chelsea House.

Bloom, Harold. (ed.) (1987b). George Orwell's 1984 (Modern Critical Interpretations). New York / New Haven / Philadelphia: Chelsea House.

Bloom, Harold. (ed.) (1999). George Orwell's Animal Farm (Modern Critical Interpretations). Philadelphia: Chelsea House.

Bell, Daniel. (1949). Untitled review of Nineteen Eighty-Four (Orwell 1949). Meyers 1975: 262-266. (Orig. New Leader, New York, 25 June 1949: p. 8.)

Bellamy, Edward. (1888). Looking Backward: 2000-1887. Boston: Houghton.

Burgess, Anthony. (1978). “Ingsoc Reconsidered.” Bloom 1987: 35-45. (Orig. Anthony Burgess, 1985. Hutchinson: 1978.)

Calder, Jenni. (1968). “Orwell's Post-War Prophecy.” Williams 1974: 133-155. (Orig. Jenni Calder. Chronicles of Conscience. London: Seeker and Warburg, 1968.)

Cassel, Gustav. (1934). “From Protectionism through Planned Economy to Dictatorship: Address Delivered in London on May 10, 1934.” International Conciliation 16 (1934-1935) 307-325. <http://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/intcon16&g_sent=1&collection=journals&id=321#321> [accessed: 11 April 2014]

Creveld, Martin van. (1999). The Rise and Decline of the State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Crick, Bernard. (1980). “The Making of Animal Farm.” Bloom 1999: 29-43. (Excerpted from Crick, George Orwell: A Life, 1980.)

Crothers, Lane. (1994). “George Orwell and the Failure of Democratic Socialism: The Problem of Political Power.” Soundings: An Interdisciplinary Journal 77:3/4 (Fall/Winter): 389-407.

Deutscher, Isaac. (1956). “1984–The Mysticism of Cruelty.” Williams 1974: 119-132. (Also rpt. Hynes 1971: 29-40 and Howe 1982: 332-343. Orig. Isaac Deutscher. Heretics and Renegades. London: Hamish Hamilton, 1956: 230-245.)

Eckstein, Arthur. (1985). “1984 and George Orwell's Other View of Capitalism.” Modern Age (March): 11-19. <http://www.unz.org/Pub/ModernAge-1985q1-00011> [accessed:26 Aug. 2015].

Epstein, Richard A. (2002). “Does Literature Work as Social Science? The Case of George Orwell.” University of Colorado Law Review vol. 73: 987-1011.

Farrant, Andrew. (2015). “Hayek, Orwell, and The Road to Serfdom.” Hayek: A Collaborative Biography: Part VI, Good Dictators, Sovereign Producers and Hayek's “Ruthless Consistency,” ed. Robert Leeson. New York: Palgrave Macmillan: 152-182.

Fergenson, Laraine. (1989). “George Orwell's Animal Farm: A Twentieth-Century Beast Fable.” Bloom 1999: 109-118. (Orig. Papers and Fables Read at the Beast Fable Society's Second International Congress Held in Copenhagen, Denmark, 1-7 August 1989.)

Harrington, Michael. (1982). “Nineteen Eighty-Four Revisited.” Howe 1982: 429-439.

Hayek, F. A. (1974). “The Pretence of Knowledge” (Nobel Prize speech). <http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/laureates/1974/hayek-lecture.html> [accessed: 26 August 2015]

Hayek, F. A. (2007). The Road to Serfdom: Texts and Documents–The Definitive Edition. Ed. Bruce Caldwell. Chicago: Chicago University Press. (Orig. Chicago: Chicago UP, 1944.)

Hazlitt, Henry. (1966). Time Will Run Back: A Novel about the Discovery of Capitalism. New Rochelle: Arlington. (Orig. The Great Idea. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1951.)

Henderson, David R. (2012-2013). “Plenty of Nothing” (review of Spufford 2012). Regulation 35:4 (Winter 2012-2013): 55-56. <http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/regulation/2013/1/v35n4-7_3.pdf#page=8> [accessed: 26 August 2015]

Higgs, Robert. (1987). Crisis and Leviathan: Critical Episodes in the Growth of American Government. New York: Oxford University Press.

Hans-Hermann Hoppe. (1993). “Marxist and Austrian Class Analysis.” Maltsev 1993: 51-73.

Hoff, Trygve J. B. (1981). Economic Calculation in the Socialist Society. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund. (Orig. London / Edinburgh / Glasgow: William Hodge, 1949. Trans. M. A. Michael from the orig. Økonomisk Kalkulasjon i Socialistiske Samfund. Oslo: H. Aschehoug, 1938.)

Howe, Irving. (1956). “1984: History as Nightmare.” Howe 1982: 320-332. (Orig. The American Scholar 25:2 [Spring 1956]:193-207.)

Howe, Irving. (1962). “The Fiction of Anti-Utopia.” Howe 1982: 303-310. (Orig. The New Republic, 23 April 1962.)

Howe, Irving. (ed.) (1982). Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four: Texts, Sources, Criticism. 2nd. ed. New York: Harcourt.

Howe, Irving. (1983). “1984: Enigmas of Power.” Bloom 1987b: 95-107. (Orig. Irving Howe, 1984 Revisited: Totalitarianism in our Century. Harper & Row, 1983.) Huxley, Aldous. (1932). Brave New World. London: Chatto, 1932.

Hynes, Samuel (ed.). (1971). Twentieth Century Interpretations of 1984. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Jewkes, John. (1968). The New Ordeal By Planning: The Experience of the Forties and Sixties. London/Melbourne/Toronto: Macmillan & New York: St. Martin's. (Updated from The Ordeal by Planning. New York: Macmillan, 1948.)

Kateb, George. (1966). “The Road to 1984.” Hynes 1971: 73-87. (Orig. Political Science Quarterly 81 [Dec. 1966]: 564-580.)

Knoll, Samson B. (1991). “Socialism as Dystopia: Political Uses of Utopian Dime Novels In Pre-World War I Germany.” Utopian Studies 4: 35-41

Letemendia, V. C. (1992). “Revolution on Animal Farm: Orwell's Neglected Commentary.” Bloom 1999: 119-129. (Orig. Journal of Modern Literature 18(1) [Winter 1992]: 127-137.)

Makovi, Michael. (2015). “George Orwell as a Public Choice Economist.” Forthcoming in The American Economist.

Makovi, Michael. (unpublished). “The Incoherence of Democratic Socialism: A Restatement.” <https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/id/eprint/66282>

Meyers, Jeffrey (ed.). (1975). George Orwell: The Critical Heritage. London and Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

More, Thomas. (1516). Utopia. London. (Orig. Latin, many translations.)

Mises, Ludwig von. (1985). Omnipotent Government: The Rise of Total State and Total War. Grove City: Libertarian Press. (Orig. Yale University Press, 1944.)

Newsinger, John. (1999). Orwell's Politics. Houndsmills, Basingstroke, New Hamphsire and New York: Palgrave.

Orwell, George (pseud. for Eric Blair). (1939a). “Review of Communism and Man by F. J. Sheed.” (Orig. Peace News, 27 Jan. 1939.) in Orwell 2002: 111-3.

Orwell, George. (1939b). “Review of Russia under Soviet Rule by N. de Basily.” (Orig. New English Weekly, 12 Jan. 1939.) in Orwell 2002: 108-11.

Orwell, George. (1941a). “The Lion and the Unicorn: Socialism and the English Genius.” (Orig. 19 February 1941.) in Orwell 2002: 291-348.

Orwell, George. (1941b). “Literature and Totalitarianism.” (Orig. broadcast 21 May 1941.) in Orwell 2002: 360-364.

Orwell, George. (1941c). “Will Freedom Die with Capitalism?” The Left News. April 1941: 1682-1685. (Rpt. in The Complete Works of George Orwell, edited by Peter Davison. London: Secker & Warburg, 1998: 458-464)

Orwell, George. (1944a). “Review of The Road to Serfdom by F.A. Hayek / The Mirror of the Past by K. Zilliacus.” (Orig. The Observer, 9 April 1944.) The Collected Essays, Journalism, and Letters of George Orwell. Nonpareil Books, 2000. (Orig. NY: Harcourt, 1968.) Vol. 3, 117-119. (Rpt. from Complete Works, publ. 2000-2002 by Secker and Warburg, vol. 6, 149-50.)

Orwell, George. (1944b). “The English People.” (Orig. written 1944, publ. 1947) in Orwell 2002: 608-648.

Orwell, George. (1945). Animal Farm. (Orig. Secker and Warburg; rpt. 1987.) Orwell 2009: 1-73.

Orwell, George. (1946a). “As I Please 63.” (Orig. Tribune, 29 November 1946.) in Orwell 2002: 1135-9.

Orwell, George. (1946b.) “The Prevention of Literature” in Orwell 2002: 931-945. (Orig. Polemic, Jan. 1946; The Atlantic Monthly, Mar. 1947. Rpt. in Howe 1982: 262-273)

Orwell, George. (1949). Nineteen Eighty-Four. (Orig. Secker and Warburg, 1949; rpt. 1987.) in Orwell 2009: 939-1186.

Orwell, George. (2002). Essays. Ed. John Carey. Everyman's Library. New York: Knopf. (Based on Complete Works, Vols. 10-20, publ. 2000-2002 by Secker and Warburg.)

Orwell, George. (2009). The Complete Novels of George Orwell. (No editor listed.) Penguin Modern Classics. London: Penguin. (Orig. Secker and Warburg, 1976; rpt. Penguin Books, 1983; Penguin Classics, 2000.)

Osterfeld, David. (1992). Prosperity Versus Planning: How Government Stifles Economic Growth. NY/Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Palmer, Tom G. (2009). “Classical Liberalism, Marxism, and the Conflict of Classes: The Classical Liberal Theory of Class Conflict.” Tom G. Palmer, Realizing Freedom: Libertarian Theory, History, and Practice (Washington, DC: The Cato Institute, 2009): 255-275.

Paterson, Isabel. (1943). The God of the Machine. NY: Putnam.

Peters, Michael. (1995). “Animal Farm Fifty Years On.” Bloom 1999: 131-133. (Orig. Contemporary Review 267:1555 [Aug. 1995]: 90-91.)

Plank, Robert. (1981). “The Modern Shrunken Utopia.” Roemer 1981: 206-230.

Rahv, Philip. (1949). “The Unfuture of Utopia.” Bloom 1987a: 13-20 & Howe 1982: 310-316 & Meyers 1975: 267-273. (Orig. Partisan Review 16:7 [1949]. Rpt. Philip Rahv. Literature and the Sixth Sense. Boston: Houghton, 1969.)

Raico, Ralph. (1974). “Classical-Liberal Exploitation Theory.” Conference paper delivered at the Second Annual Libertarian Scholars' Conference, New York City, 26 Oct. 261974. <https://mises.org/library/classical-liberal-exploitation-theory-0> [accessed: 26 Aug. 2015]

Raico, Ralph. (1990). “Eugen Richter and Late German Manchester Liberalism: A Reevaluation.” The Review of Austrian Economics 4 (1990): 3-25. <http://mises.org/journals/rae/pdf/rae4_1_1.pdf> [accessed: 2 February 2014]. (Rpt. as “Eugen Richter and the End of German Liberalism,” <http://mises.org/daily/4503> [accessed: 2 February 2014].)

Raico, Ralph. (1993). “Classical Liberal Roots of the Marxist Doctrine of Classes” in Maltev 1993: 189-220. Reilly, Patrick. (1986). “The Utopian Shipwreck.” Bloom 1999: 61-89. (Orig. Reilly, George Orwell: The Age's Adversary, 1986.)

Richman, Sheldon. (2011). “From 1944 to Nineteen Eighty-Four: A Tale of Two Books.” The Freeman. The Foundation for Economic Education, 16 Dec. 2011 (rpt. from vol. 59, December 2009). <http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/from-1944-to-nineteen-eighty-four> [accessed: 2 February 2014]

Richter, Eugen. (2010). Pictures of the Socialistic Future (Freely adapted from Bebel). Auburn: Mises Institute. (Orig. Sozialdemokratische Zukunftsbilder: Frei nach Bebel, 1891. Trans. Henry Wright. London: Swan Sonnenschein, 1893.)

Ritter, Claus. (1960). Start nach Utopolis. Eine Zukunfts-Nostalgie. Berlin: Verlag der Nation.

Roback, Jennifer. (1985). “The Economic Thought of George Orwell.” The American Economic Review 75:2 (May): 127-132.

Roemer, Kenneth M. (ed.). (1981). America as Utopia. New York: Burt Franklin.

Rothbard, Murray. (1991). “The End of Socialism and the Calculation Debate Revisited.” The Review of Austrian Economics 5(1): 51-76. <http://mises.org/journals/rae/pdf/rae5_2_3.pdf> [accessed: 1 April 2014].

Sargent, Lyman Tower. (1981). “Capitalist Eutopias in America.” Roemer 1981: 192-205.

Schivelbusch, Wolfgang. (2006). Three New Deals: Reflections on Roosevelt’s America, Mussolini’s Italy, and Hitler’s Germany, 1933–1939. New York: Metropolitan Books.

Smyer, Richard I. (1971). “Animal Farm: The Burden of Consciousness.” Bloom 1999: 25-28. (Rpt. from English Language Notes 9:1 [Sept.].)

Spender, Stephen. (1965). “Introduction to 1984.” Hynes 1971: 62-72. (Orig. “Introduction” to 1984 by George Orwell. London: Heinemann Educational Books, 1965: vii-xxi.]

Spufford, Francis. (2012). Red Plenty. Minneapolis: Graywolf Press.

Steele, David Ramsay. (1992). From Marx to Mises: Post-Capitalist Society and the Challenge of Economic Calculation. La Salle: Open Court.

Trilling, Lionel. (1949). “Orwell on the Future.” Hynes 1971: 24-28. (Orig. The New Yorker, 18 June 1949: 74-77.)

Weinburg, Mark. (1978). “The Social Analysis of Three Early 19th Century French Liberals: Say, Comte, and Dunoyer.” Journal of Libertarian Studies 2(1): 45-63. <https://mises.org/library/social-analysis-three-early-19th-century-french-liberals-say-comte-and-dunoyer> [accessed” 26 Oct. 2015]

White, Richard. (2008). “George Orwell: Socialism and Utopia.” Utopian Studies 19(1): 73-95.

Williams, Raymond (ed.). (1974). George Orwell: A Collection of Critical Essays (Twentieth Century Views). Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.

Zamiatin, Yevgeny. (1921). We. Many translators and publishers; written 1921 in Russian, first published as: Trans. Gregory Zilboorg. NY: E. P. Dutton, 1924.

Zwerdling, Alex. (1971). “Orwell and the Techniques of Didactic Fantasy.” Hynes 1971: 88-101.