Multidimensional Analysis of Attainment of Higher Education Goals in South Africa’s Public Universities: Access, Quality, Diversity, Success and Efficiency

Badunenko, Oleg and Myeki, Lindikaya W (2023): Multidimensional Analysis of Attainment of Higher Education Goals in South Africa’s Public Universities: Access, Quality, Diversity, Success and Efficiency.

Abstract

The National Development Plan in South Africa aims to combat inequality. The Department of Higher Education and Training has identified goals for public universities not only to improve knowledge creation, transmission, and exchange but also equity. This paper analyzes the degree to which universities are successful in meeting the goals. We use a novel approach that allows disentangling persistent and transient underachievement to investigate achievement and their determinants of the traditional, comprehensive, and technology universities in South Africa from 2009 to 2016. We find contrary to previous studies that technology universities are the top performers, followed by comprehensive universities, while traditional universities have the lowest achievement levels. Additionally, the study demonstrates that although all types of universities exhibit comparable transient underachievement, the overall underachievement of comprehensive and traditional universities is primarily driven by persistent or long-term factors. The findings carry important implications for effectively executing the objectives determined by policymakers.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Higher Education; South Africa; Inequality; Underachivement; Government Policy
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H52 - Government Expenditures and Education; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I23 - Higher Education ; Research Institutions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I24 - Education and Inequality; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I28 - Government Policy

References

Agasisti, T. and Gralka, S.: 2019, The transient and persistent efficiency of Italian and German universities: A stochastic frontier analysis, Applied Economics 51(46), 5012– 5030.

Aigner, D., Lovell, C. A. K. and Schmidt, P.: 1977, Formulation and estimation of stochas- tic frontier production function models, Journal of Econometrics 6(1), 21–37.

Amina, N. and Turyahebwa, A.: 2015, Institutional efficiency in selected universities in Uganda, Journal of Education and Practice 6(10), 90–96.

Andersson, C., Antelius, J., Månsson, J. and Sund, K.: 2017, Technical efficiency and productivity for higher education institutions in Sweden, Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 61(2), 205–223.

Arjomandi, A., Salleh, M. I. and Mohammadzadeh, A.: 2015, Measuring productivity change in higher education: an application of Hicks–Moorsteen total factor produc- tivity index to Malaysian public universities, Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy 20(4), 630–643.

Badat, S.: 2012, Redressing the Colonial/Apartheid Legacy: Social equity, redress and Higher Education admissions in democratic South Africa, Conference on Affirmative Action in Higher Education in India, the United States and South Africa. New Delhi, India, Oxford University Press, pp. 19–21.

Badunenko, O. and Kumbhakar, S. C.: 2017, Economies of scale, technical change and persistent and time-varying cost efficiency in Indian banking: Do ownership, regulation and heterogeneity matter?, European Journal of Operational Research 260(2), 789–803.

Badunenko, O., Mazrekaj, D., Kumbhakar, S. and De Witte, K.: 2021, Persistent and transient inefficiency in adult education, 60, 2925–2942.

Ballard, R., Habib, A., Valodia, I. and Zuern, E.: 2005, Globalization, marginalization and contemporary social movements in South Africa, African Affairs 104(417), 615– 634.

Beresford, A.: 2015, Power, patronage, and gatekeeper politics in South Africa, African Affairs 114(455), 226–248.

Bornmann, L., Gralka, S., de Moya Anegón, F. and Wohlrabe, K.: 2023, Efficiency of uni- versities and research-focused institutions worldwide: The introduction of a new input indicator reflecting institutional staff numbers, Journal of Informetrics 17(2), 101400.

Boughey, C.: 2003, From equity to efficiency: Access to higher education in South Africa, Arts and Humanities in Higher Education 2(1), 65–71.

Bunting, I.: 1994, A legacy of inequality: Higher education in South Africa, Juta and Company Ltd.

Caudill, S. B., Ford, J. M. and Gropper, D. M.: 1995, Frontier Estimation and Firm- Specific Inefficiency Measures in the Presence of Heteroscedasticity, Journal of Busi- ness & Economic Statistics 13(1), 105–111.

Cloete, N., Bunting, I. and Van Schalkwyk, F.: 2018, Research universities in Africa, African Minds.

Cloete, N. and Moja, T.: 2005, Transformation tensions in higher education: Equity, efficiency, and development, Social Research: An International Quarterly 72(3), 693– 722.

Council on Higher Education: 2016, South African higher education reviewed: Two decades of democracy.

Cunningham, J. A., Lehmann, E. E., Menter, M. and Seitz, N.: 2019, The impact of uni- versity focused technology transfer policies on regional innovation and entrepreneur- ship, The Journal of Technology Transfer 44(5), 1451–1475.

Department of Higher Education and Training: 2013, White paper for post-school educa- tion and training: Building an expanded, effective and integrated post-school system, DHET.

Department of Higher Education and Training: 2019, Post-School Education and Train- ing Monitor report, the Macro-Indicator Trends, DHET.

Department of Higher Education and Training: 2021, Statistics on Post-School Educa- tion and Training in South Africa 2019, DHET.

Ferreyra, M. M., Avitabile, C., Paz, F. H. et al.: 2017, At a crossroads: higher education in Latin America and the Caribbean, World Bank Publications.

Ferro, G. and D’Elia, V.: 2020, Higher education efficiency frontier analysis: A review of variables to consider., Journal on Efficiency and Responsibility in Education and Science 13(3), 140–153.

Godsell, G., Chikane, R. and Mpofu-Walsh, S.: 2016, Fees must fall: Student revolt, decolonisation and governance in South Africa, NYU Press.

Gralka, S.: 2018a, Persistent inefficiency in the higher education sector: Evidence from Germany, Education Economics 26(4), 373–392.

Gralka, S.: 2018b, Stochastic frontier analysis in higher education: A systematic review, CEPIE Working Papers 05/18, Technische Universität Dresden, Center of Public and International Economics (CEPIE).

Guccio, C., Martorana, M. F. and Monaco, L.: 2016, Evaluating the impact of the Bologna process on the efficiency convergence of Italian universities: A non-parametric frontier approach, Journal of Productivity Analysis 45(3), 275–298.

Jiang, J., Lee, S. K. and Rah, M.-J.: 2020, Assessing the research efficiency of Chinese higher education institutions by Data Envelopment Analysis, Asia Pacific Education Review 21(3), 423–440.

Johnes, G. and Schwarzenberger, A.: 2011, Differences in cost structure and the evalu- ation of efficiency: the case of German universities, Education Economics 19(5), 487– 499.

Johnes, J. and Li, Y.: 2008, Measuring the research performance of Chinese higher education institutions using Data Envelopment Analysis, China Economic Review 19(4), 679–696.

Kiwanuka, N. R.: 2015, Technical efficiency and total factor productivity growth of se- lected public universities in Africa: 2000-2007, PhD thesis, Makerere University.

Kruss, G. and Visser, M.: 2017, Putting university–industry interaction into perspective: A differentiated view from inside South African universities, The Journal of Technol- ogy Transfer 42, 884–908.

Lange, L.: 2017, 20 years of higher education curriculum policy in South Africa, Journal of Education (68), 31–57.

Laureti, T., Secondi, L. and Biggeri, L.: 2014, Measuring the efficiency of teaching activ- ities in Italian universities: An information theoretic approach, Economics of Educa- tion Review 42, 147–164.

Legodi, L. T. and Shai, K. B.: 2018, The shackles of colonialism in South African univer- sities: an afrocentric analysis, Commonwealth Youth and Development 16(1), 1–11.

Lemon, A.: 2005, Shifting geographies of social inclusion and exclusion: Secondary edu- cation in pietermaritzburg, South Africa, African Affairs 104(414), 69–96.

Lu, Y.-H. and Chen, K.-H.: 2013, Appraising the cost efficiency of higher technological and vocational education institutions in Taiwan using the metafrontier cost-function model, Research in Higher Education 54(6), 627–663.

Mabokela, R. O. and Mlambo, Y. A.: 2017, Access and equity and South African higher education: A review of policies after 20 years of democracy, Comparative Education Review 61(4), 780–803.

Marire, J.: 2017, Are South African public universities economically efficient? Reflection amidst higher education crisis, South African Journal of Higher Education 31(3), 116– 137.

Matsheka, D., Garutsa, T. et al.: 2022, Challenges faced by racial minority students at Justus-Liebig University, Germany and North-West University, South Africa, Interna- tional Journal of Higher Education 11(7), 13–23.

Meeusen, W. and van den Broeck, J.: 1977, Efficiency estimation from Cobb-Douglas production functions with composed error, International Economic Review 18(2), 435– 444.

Mohuba, D. K. and Govender, K.: 2016, The merger of historically disadvantaged ter- tiary institutions in South Africa: A case study of the University of Limpopo, Cogent Business & Management 3(1), 1258133.

Moodley, P. and Singh, R. J.: 2015, Addressing student dropout rates at South African universities, Alternation (Durban) .

Murray, M.: 2014, Factors affecting graduation and student dropout rates at the univer- sity of KwaZulu-Natal, South African Journal of Science 110(11-12), 01–06.

Muswede, T.: 2017, Colonial legacies and the decolonisation discourse in post-apartheid South Africa — A reflective analysis of student activism in higher education, African Journal of Public Affairs 9(5), 200–210.

Myeki, L. and Temoso, O.: 2019, Efficiency assessment of public universities in south africa, 2009-2013: Panel data evidence, South African Journal of Higher Education 33(5), 264–280.

Mzangwa, S. T.: 2019, The effects of higher education policy on transformation in post- apartheid South Africa, Cogent Education 6(1), 1592737.

Nkohla, T., Munacinga, C. S., Marwa, N. and Ncwadi, R.: 2021, A non-parametric as- sessment of efficiency of South African public universities, South African Journal of Higher Education 35(2), 158–187.

NPC: 2012, National development plan 2030: Our future-make it work, Technical report, The Presidency of the Republic of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa.

Pattman, R.: 2007, Student identities, and researching these, in a newly ‘racially’ merged university in South Africa, Race Ethnicity and Education 10(4), 473–492.

Rehman, S., Bisschoff, C. and Botha, C.: 2019, A model to measure academic perfor- mance of private higher education institutions, Journal of Contemporary Management 16(2), 178–200.

Reifschneider, D. and Stevenson, R.: 1991, Systematic Departures from the Frontier: A Framework for the Analysis of Firm Inefficiency, International Economic Review 32(3), 715–723.

Rhaiem, M.: 2017, Measurement and determinants of academic research efficiency: a systematic review of the evidence, Scientometrics 110(2), 581–615.

Sav, G.: 2012a, Managing operating efficiencies of publicly owned universities: American university stochastic frontier estimates using panel data, Advances in Management and Applied Economics 2(1), 1.

Sav, G. T.: 2012b, Stochastic cost inefficiency estimates and rankings of public and pri- vate research and doctoral granting universities, Journal of Knowledge Management, Economics, and Information Technology 2(3).

Siemens, G., Dawson, S. and Lynch, G.: 2013, Improving the quality and productivity of the higher education sector, Policy and Strategy for Systems-Level Deployment of Learning Analytics. Canberra, Australia: Society for Learning Analytics Research for the Australian Office for Learning and Teaching 31.

Steiner, L., Sundström, A. C. and Sammalisto, K.: 2013, An analytical model for univer- sity identity and reputation strategy work, Higher Education 65(4), 401–415.

Swain, S. G.: 2013, Diversity education goals in higher education: A policy discourse analysis, The University of Maine.

Swartz, R., Ivancheva, M., Czerniewicz, L. and Morris, N. P.: 2019, Between a rock and a hard place: Dilemmas regarding the purpose of public universities in South Africa, Higher Education 77, 567–583.

Temoso, O. and Myeki, L. W.: 2022, Estimating South African higher education produc- tivity and its determinants using Färe-Primont index: Are historically disadvantaged universities catching up?, Research in Higher Education pp. 1–22.

Temoso, O., Tran, C.-T. T. D. and Myeki, L.: 2023, Network dea efficiency of South African higher education: evidence from the analysis of teaching and research at the univer- sity level, Journal of Further and Higher Education pp. 1–18.

Uyarra, E.: 2010, Conceptualizing the regional roles of universities, implications and contradictions, European Planning Studies 18(8), 1227–1246.

Van der Berg, S.: 2007, Apartheid’s enduring legacy: Inequalities in education, Journal of African economies 16(5), 849–880.

Verwey, C. and Quayle, M.: 2012, Whiteness, racism, and afrikaner identity in post- apartheid South Africa, African Affairs 111(445), 551–575.

Walker, M. and Mathebula, M.: 2020, Low-income rural youth migrating to urban uni- versities in South Africa: opportunities and inequalities, Compare: A Journal of Com- parative and International Education 50(8), 1193–1209.

Witte, K. D. and López-Torres, L.: 2017, Efficiency in education: a review of literature and a way forward, Journal of the Operational Research Society 68(4), 339–363.

Wolszczak-Derlacz, J.: 2017, An evaluation and explanation of (in) efficiency in higher education institutions in Europe and the US with the application of two-stage semi- parametric DEA, Research Policy 46(9), 1595–1605.

Worthington, A. and Lee, B.: 2008, Efficiency, technology and productivity change in australian universities, 1998–2003, Economics of Education Review 27(3), 285–298.

Yang, J., Wang, C., Liu, L., Croucher, G., Moore, K. and Coates, H.: 2020, The produc- tivity of leading global universities: Empirical insights and implications for higher education, Responsibility of Higher Education Systems, Brill, pp. 224–249.

Zoghbi, A. C., Rocha, F. and Mattos, E.: 2013, Education production efficiency: Evidence from Brazilian universities, Economic Modelling 31, 94–103.