Standardizing the fiscal state: cabal tax farming as an Intermediate Institution in early-modern England and France

Noel D., Johnson and Mark, Koyama (2012): Standardizing the fiscal state: cabal tax farming as an Intermediate Institution in early-modern England and France.

Abstract

How did modern and centralized fiscal institutions emerge? We develop a model that explains (i) why pre-industrial states relied on private individuals to collect taxes; (ii) why after 1600 both England and France moved from competitive methods for collecting revenues to allocating the right to collect taxes to a small group of financiers—a intermediate institution that we call cabal tax farming—and (iii) why this centralization led to investments in fiscal capacity and increased fiscal standardization. We provide detailed historical evidence that supports our prediction that rulers abandoned the competitive allocation of tax rights in favor of cabal tax farming in order to gain access to inside credit and that this transition was accompanied by investments in standardization. Finally (iv) we show why this intermediate institution proved to be self-undermining in England where it was quickly replaced by direct collection, but lasted in France until the French Revolution.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: State Capacity; Standardization; Tax Farming; France; England; Transaction Costs
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N2 - Financial Markets and Institutions > N23 - Europe: Pre-1913; H - Public Economics > H1 - Structure and Scope of Government > H11 - Structure, Scope, and Performance of Government; K - Law and Economics > K0 - General > K00 - General; D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D02 - Institutions: Design, Formation, Operations, and Impact; N - Economic History > N4 - Government, War, Law, International Relations, and Regulation > N44 - Europe: 1913-

References

Allen, Doug (2000), Transaction costs, in B.Bouckaert and G.De Geest, eds, ‘Encyclopedia of Law and Eco- nomics (Volume One: The History and Methodology of Law and Economics’, Edward Elgar, Chelthenham, pp. 893–926.

Allen, Douglas W. (2005), ‘Purchase, Patronage, and Professions: Incentives and the Evolution of Public Office in Pre-Modern Britain’, Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 161(1), 57–79.

Allen, Douglas W. (2012), The Institutional Revolution, Chicago University Press, Chicago.

Ashton, Robert (1956), ‘Revenue farming under the early Stuarts’, The Economic History Review 8(3), pp. 310–322.

Ashton, Robert (1957), ‘Deficit finance in the reign of James I’, The Economic History Review 10(1), pp. 15–29.

Ashton, Robert (1960), The Crown and the Money Market, 1603-1640, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Ashton, Robert (1979), The City and the Court, 1603–1643, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Ashworth, William J. (2003), Customs and Excise: Trade, Production, and Consumption in England, 1640– 1845, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Aylmer, G.E. (1961), The Civil Service of Charles I, Columbia University Press, New York.

Baker, Robert L. (1961), ‘The English customs service, 1307-1343: A study of medieval administration’, Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 51(6), pp. 3–76.

Balla, Eliana and Noel D. Johnson (2009), ‘Fiscal crisis and institutional change in the Ottoman Empire and France’, The Journal of Economic History 69(03), 809–845. Barzel, Yoram (1997, 1989), Economic Analysis of Property Rights, 2nd edn, CUP, Cambridge, UK.

Bayard, Francoise (1988), Le Monde des financiers au xviie si`ecle, Flammarion, Paris.

Bell, Adrian R., Chris Brooks and Tony K. Moore (2009), Accounts of the English Crown with Italian Merchant Societies, 1272-1345, List and Index Society, Kew.

Bell, Adrian R., Chris Brooks and Tony K. Moore (2011), ‘Credit finance in thirteenth century England: the Ricciardi of Lucca and Edward I, 1272–1294’, Thirteenth Century England XIII, 101–116.

Besley, Timothy and Torsten Persson (2009), ‘The origins of state capacity: Property rights, taxation, and politics’, American Economic Review 99(4), 1218–44.

Besley, Timothy and Torsten Persson (2011), Pillars of Prosperity, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.

Bonney, M. and R. Bonney (1993), Jean-Roland Malet Premier Historien des Finances de la Monarchie Fran ̧caise, Comit ́e pour l’Histoire Economique et Financiere de la France, Paris.

Bonney, R. J. (1979), ‘The failure of the French revenue farms, 1600-60’, The Economic History Review 32(1), pp. 11–32.

Bonney, Richard, ed. (1995), The Rise of the Fiscal State in Europe c.1200-1815, Clarendon Press, OUP, Oxford.

Bonney, Richard, ed. (1999), Economic Systems and State Finance, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Bonney, Richard and Margaret Bonney (2011). URL: http://esfdb.websites.bta.com/Database.aspx

Braddick, Michael J. (1994), Parliamentary Taxation in Seventeenth-Century England, The Royal Historical Society: The Boydell Press, Woodbridge, Suffolk.

Braddick, Michael J. (1996), Nerves of State: Taxation and the financing of the English State, 1558–1714, Manchester University Press, Manchester.

Brenner, Robert (1976), ‘Agarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe’, Past and Present 70(1), 30–75.

Brenner, Robert (1993), Merchants and Revolution, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. Brewer, John (1988), The Sinews of Power, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, M.A.

Carruthers, Bruce G. (1996), City of Capital: Politics and Markets in the English Financial Revolution, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.

Cassidy, Irene (1983), Bucknall, Sir William (1633-76), of London and Oxhey, Hert, in ‘History of Parliament 1660-1690’.

Chanda, Areendam and Louis Putterman (2007), ‘Early starts, reversals and catch-up in the process of economic development’, Scandinavian Journal of Economics 109(2), 387–413.

Chandaman, C.D. (1975), The English Public Revenue 1660–1688, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Coase, R. H. (1960), ‘The problem of social cost’, The Journal of Law and Economics 3(1), 1.

Coffman, D’Maris Dalton (2007), “The power of the king to be without parliament”: a new look at an old interpretation of the financial settlement of 1690. Conference paper.

Coffman, D’Maris Dalton (2008), The Fiscal Revolution of the Interregnum: Excise taxation in the British Isles, 1643-1663, Dissertation, University of Pennsylvania.

Colbert, J.B. (1869), Lettres, instructions et m ́emoires: Justice et police. Affaires religieuses. Affaires diverses, number v. 6 in ‘Lettres, instructions et m ́emoires: Justice et police. Affaires religieuses. Affaires diverses’, Imprimerie Imp ́eriale.

Cosgel, Metin M. and Thomas J. Miceli (2009), ‘Tax collection in history’, Public Finance Review 37(4), 399–420.

Cramsie, John (2000), ‘Commercial projects and the fiscal policy of James VI and I’, The Historical Journal 43(2), pp. 345–364.

Crews, C.C. (1936), ‘The last period of the great farm of the English customs’, Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Research 14(41), 118–121.

Davenant, Charles (1967, 1697), Whether to farm the revenues, may not, in this jucture, be the most for the public service, in ‘The Political and Commercial Works of that celebrated Writer Charles D’Avenant, LL.D.’, Gregg Press Limited, Fairnborough, pp. 207–232.

Dessert, Daniel (1984), Argent, Pouvoir Et Soci ́et ́e au Grand Si`ecle, Fayard, Paris. Dessert, Daniel and J. L. Journet (1975), ‘Le lobby colbert: Un royaume, ou une affaire de famille?’, Annales E.S.C. 30, 1303–36.

Dickson, P.G.M. (1967), The Financial Revolution in England, Gregg Revivals, Aldershot.

Dietz, Frederick C. (1930), ‘Elizabethan customs administration’, The English Historical Review 45(177), pp. 35–57.

Dietz, Frederick C. (1932), English Public Finance 1485–1641, Vol. II: 1558–1641, Barnes & Noble, INC, New York.

Dincecco, Mark (2009), ‘Fiscal centralization, limited government, and public revenues in Europe, 1650-1913’, Journal of Economic History 69(1), 48–103.

Dincecco, Mark (2011), Political Transformations and Public Finances: Europe, 1650-1913, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Drelichman, Mauricio and Hans-Joachim Voth (2011a), ‘Lending to the borrower from hell: Debt and default in the age of Philip II’, The Economic Journal pp. 1205–1228.

Drelichman, Mauricio and Hans-Joachim Voth (2011b), ‘Serial defaults, serial profits: Returns to sovereign lending in Habsburg Spain, 1566-1600’, Explorations in Economic History 48(1), 1–19.

Drobak, John N. and John V.C. Nye (1997), The Frontiers of the New Institutional Economics, Academic Press, San Diego, California.

Durand, Yves (1971), Les Fermiers G ́en ́eraux au XVIIIe Si`ecle., Presses Universitaires de France, Paris. Epstein, S. R. (2000), Freedom and Growth, the rise of states and markets in Europe, 1300–1700, Routledge, London.

Ertman, Thomas (1997), Birth of Leviathan, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Evans, Peter, Dietrich Rueschemeyer and Theda Skocpol, eds (1985), Bringing the State Back In, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

Finer, S.E. (1999), The History of Government from the Earliest Times, Vol. III, Oxford University Press, Oxford. Franck,

Raphael, Noel D. Johnson and John V. C. Nye (2012), From internal taxes to national regulation: Evidence from a French wine tax reform at the turn of the twentieth century. Manuscript.

Fryde, E. B. (1959), ‘The English Farmers of the Customs, 1343-51’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 9, pp. 1–17.

Fryde, E. B. (1991), ‘Royal fiscal systems and state formation in France from the 13th to the 16th century, with some English comparisons’, Journal of Historical Sociology 4(3), 236–287.

Fukuyama, Francis (2011), The Origins of Political Order, Profile Books Ltd., London.

Gennaioli, Nicola and Hans-Joachim Voth (2011), State capacity and military conflict, CEPR Discussion Papers 8699, C.E.P.R. Discussion Papers.

Goldsmith, Raymond W. (1987), Premodern Financial Systems, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Gras, N. S. B. (1912), ‘The origin of the national customs-revenue of England’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics 27(1), pp. 107–149.

Greenshields, M.R. (1994), An economy of violence in early modern France: crime and justice in the Haute Auvergne, 1587-1664, Pennsylvania State University Press.

Harper, W. Percy (1929), ‘The significance of the farmers of the customs in public finance in the middle of the seventeenth century’, Economica (25), pp. 61–70.

Hart, Marjolen’T (1991), “The devil of the Dutch’: Holland’s impact on the Financial Revolution in England, 1643–1694’, Parliaments, Estates, and Representation 11(1), 39–51.

Heckscher, Eli F. (1955), Mercantilism, Vol. I, George Allen & Unwin LTD, London. translated by E.F. Soderlund.

Heumann, Pierre (1938), Un traitant sous louis xiii: Antoine feydeau, in M. G.Pag`es, ed., ‘E ́tudes sur l’Histoire Administrative et Sociale de l’Ancien R ́egime’, Librairie F ́elix Alcan, Paris, pp. 185–89.

Hoffman, Philip T. (1994), Early modern France, 1450-1700, in P. T.Hoffman and K.Norberg, eds, ‘Fiscal crises, liberty, and representative government, 1450-1789’, Stanford University Press, Stanford, Calif.

Holmes, Geoffrey (1993), The Making of a Great Power, Longman, London.

Hoon, Elizabeth Evelyonola (1968), The Organization of the English Customs System, 1696–1786, David & Charles, Newton Abbot, Devon.

Howard, Stanley (1932), ‘Private rules for private accounting in France, 1673 and 1807’, The Accounting Review 7(2).

Hyde, Edward (1760a), The Life of Edward Hyde Earl of Clarendon, Vol. 3, J.J. Toureneisen, Basil.

Hyde, Edward (1760b), The Life of Edward Hyde Earl of Clarendon, Vol. 2, J.J. Toureneisen, Basil.

Johnson, Noel D. (2006a), ‘Banking on the King: The evolution of the royal revenue farms in old regime France’, The Journal of Economic History 66(04), 963–991.

Johnson, Noel D. (2006b), ‘The cost of credibility: The company of general farms and fiscal stagnation in eighteenth century France’, Essays in Economic and Business History 24.

Johnson, Noel D. and Mark Koyama (2011), Taxes, lawyers, and the decline of witchcraft. Manuscript.

Johnson, Noel D., Mark Koyama and John V.C. Nye (2011), Establishing a New Order: The Growth of the State and the Decline of Witch Trials in France. Manuscript.

Jones, J.R. (1979), Main trends in restoration England, in J.Jones, ed., ‘The Restored Monarchy 1660–1688’, Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Totowa, New Jersey, pp. 1–30.

Jourdan, Decrusy, Isambert, Armet and Taillander (1822-30), Recueil g ́en ́eral des anciennes lois fran ̧caise, 29 vols, Belin-Le-Prieur Verdiere, Paris.

Kaeuper, Richard W. (1973), Bankers to the Crown: the Riccardi of Lucca and Edward I, Princeton Univer- sity Press, Princeton, U.S.A.

Karaman, K. Kivanc ̧ and Sevket Pamuk (2011), Different paths to the modern state in Europe: The interaction between domestic political economy and interstate competition, Europe in Question Discussion Paper Series of the London School of Economics (LEQs) 7, London School of Economics / European Institute.

Kiser, Edgar and April Linton (2001), ‘Determinants of the growth of the state: War and taxation in early modern France and England’, Social Forces 80(2), pp. 411–448.

Kiser, Edgar and Joachim Schneider (1994), ‘Bureaucracy and efficiency: An analysis of taxation in early modern Prussia’, American Sociological Review 59(2), pp. 187–204.

Kiser, Edgar and Joshua Kane (2001), ‘Revolution and state structure: The bureaueratization of tax administration in early modern England and France’, American Journal of Sociology 107(1), 183–223.

Kishansky, Mark (1996), A Monarchy Transformed: Britain 1603–1714, Penguin Books, London.

Lyon, B.D. and A.E. Verhulst (1967), Medieval finance: a comparison of financial institutions in northwestern Europe, Brown University Press.

Markoff, J. (1996), The Abolition of Feudalism: Peasants, Lords, and Legislators in the French Revolution, Pennsylvania State University Press.

Matthews, George T. (1958), The Royal General Farms in Eighteenth-Century France, Columbia University Press, New York.

Maurer, Noel and Andrei Gomberg (2004), ‘When the state is untrustworthy: Public finance and private banking in Porfirian Mexico’, The Journal of Economic History 64(04), 1087–1107.

Morris, W.A. and JNR. Strayer (1947), The English Government at Work, Vol. 2: 1327-1336, Medieval Academy of America.

Nichols, G.O. (1971), ‘English government borrowing, 1660-1688’, The Journal of British Studies 10(2), 83–104.

North, Douglass C. (1981), Structure and Change in Economic History, Norton, New York, U.S.A.

North, Douglass C. (1990), Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance, Cambridge UP, Cambridge, U.K.

North, Douglass C. and Barry Weingast (1989), ‘Constitutions and commitment: the evolution of institutions governing public choice in seventeenth century England’, Journal of Economic History 49, 803–32.

North, Douglass C., John Joseph Wallis and Barry R. Weingast (2009), Violence and Social Orders: a conceptual framework for interpreting recorded human history, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

North, Douglass C. and Robert Paul Thomas (1973), The Rise of the Western World, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.

Nye, John (2008), Institutions and the institutional environment, in E.Brousseau and J.-M.Glachant, eds, ‘New Institutional Economics, a guidebook’, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 67–81.

O’Brien, Patrick K. (1988), ‘The political economy of British taxation, 1660-1815’, The Economic History Review 41(1), 1–32.

O’Brien, Patrick K. (2001), Fiscal exceptionalism: Great Britain and its European Rivals from Civil War to Triumph at Trafalgar and Waterloo. LSE Working Paper.

O’Brien, Patrick K. (2011), ‘The nature and historical evolution of an exceptional fiscal state and its possible significance for the precocious commercialization and industrialization of the British economy from Cromwell to Nelson’, The Economic History Review .

O’Brien, Patrick K. and Philip A. Hunt (1999), England, 1485–1815, in R.Bonney, ed., ‘The Rise of the Fiscal State in Europe c.1200-1815’, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 53–101.

Outhwaite, R. B. (1971), ‘Royal borrowing in the reign of Elizabeth I: The aftermath of Antwerp’, The English Historical Review 86(339), pp. 251–263.

Parker, Geoffrey (1976), ‘The ”military revolution,” 1560-1660–a myth?’, The Journal of Modern History 48(2), pp. 195–214.

Peck, L.L. (1993), Court patronage and corruption in early Stuart England, Psychology Press.

Picot, Georges (1979), Histoire Des E ́tats Generaux, Consideres Au Point de Vue de Leur Influence Sur Le Gouvernement de la France De 1355 A` 1614, Vol. 1, M ́egariotis Reprints, Geneve.

Pincus, Steven C.A. and James A. Robinson (2011), What really happened during the Glorious Revolution?, Working Paper 17206, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Pitt, Catherine Rachel (2006), The wine trade in Bristol in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, Master’s thesis, Bristol University.

Prestwich, Mena (1966), Cranfield, Politics and Profits under the Early Stuarts, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Quinn, Stephen (1997), ‘Goldsmith-banking: Mutual acceptance and interbanker clearing in restoration London’, Explorations in Economic History 34(4), 411–432.

Quinn, Stephen (2001), ‘The Glorious Revolution’s effect on English private finance: A microhistory, 1680 1705’, The Journal of Economic History 61(03), 593–615.

Ramsay, G. D. (1952), ‘The smugglers’ trade: A neglected aspect of English commercial development’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 2, pp. 131–157.

Read, Conveys (1925), Mr Secretary: Walsingham and the policy of Queen Elizabeth, Vol. III, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Renauldon, Joseph (1765), Traite historique et pratique des droits seigneuriaux, Despilly, Paris. Rigby, S.H. (1985), ‘The customs administration at Boston in the reign of Richard II’, Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Research 58(137), 12–24.

Root, Hilton (1989), ‘Tying the king’s hands: Credible commitments and royal fiscal policy during the old regime’, Rationality and Society 1(2), 240–59.

Root, Hilton L. (1987), Peasants and King in Burgundy: Agrarian Foundations of French Absolutism, University of California Press. Rosevere, Henry (1969), The Treasury: The Evolution of a British Institution, Columbia University Press, New York.

Rosevere, Henry (1991), The Financial Revolution 1660–1760, Longman, London.

Savary, Jacques (1675), Le parfait n ́egociant, Chez Jean Guignard.

Scott, Jonathan (2003), ‘‘Good Night Amsterdam’. Sir George Downing and Anglo-Dutch statebuilding’, The English Historical Review 118(476), 334–356.

Sharpe, Kevin (1992), The Personal Rule of Charles I, Yale University Press, New Haven.

Shaw, William Arthur (1902), The beginnings of the national debt, in T.Trout and J.Tait, eds, ‘Historical essays by members of the Owens college, Manchester’, Longman Green, and Co., London, pp. 391–422.

Stasavage, David (2002), ‘Credible commitment in early modern Europe: North and Weingast revisited’, Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 18(1), 155–86.

Stasavage, David (2010), ‘When distance mattered: Geographic scale and the development of European representative assemblies’, American Political Science Review 104(4), 625–643.

Stasavage, David (2011), States of Credit: Size, Power, and the Development of European Polities, Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J.

Strayer, J.R. (1936), The royal domain in the bailliage of Rouen, Princeton university press.

Sussman, Nathan and Yishay Yafeh (2006), ‘Institutional reforms, financial development and sovereign debt: Britain 1690–1790’, The Journal of Economic History 66(04), 906–935.

Tawney, R.H. (1958), Business and Politics under James I, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Thomas, David (1983), Financial and administrative developments, in H.Tomlinson, ed., ‘Before the English Civil War’, St. Martin’s Press, New York.

Tilly, Charles (1975), Reflections on the history of European state-making, in C.Tilly, ed., ‘The Formation of Nation States in Western Europe’, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, pp. 3–84.

Tilly, Charles (1990), Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990-1990, Blackwell, Oxford. Tomlinson, Howard (1979), Financial and administrative developments in England, 1660–1688, in J.Jones, ed., ‘The Restored Monarchy 1660–1688’, Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Totowa, New Jersey, pp. 94– 118.

van der Wer, Herman (1977), Money, credit and banking systems, in E.Rich and C.Wilson, eds, ‘The Cambridge Economic History of Europe’, Vol. V: The Economic Organization of Early Modern Europe, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 290–393.

White, Eugene N. (2004), ‘From privatized to government-administered tax collection: tax farming in eighteenth-century France’, The Economic History Review 57(4), 636–663.

Wilson, Charles (1984), England’s Apprenticeship, 1603–1763, second edition edn, Long Group Limited, London.

Wolfe, Martin (1972), The Fiscal System of Renaissance France, Yale University Press, New Haven.